Cedarhurst, tucked in the heart of the Five Towns in Hempstead, NY, is a food lover’s treasure chest. Whether you’re looking for upscale dining, cozy cafés, artisanal bakeries, or quick bites, this lively village has a table waiting for you. Locals know the pulse of Cedarhurst beats along Central Avenue, where the streets hum with the aroma of freshly baked challah, Mediterranean spices, and gourmet sips. Here’s your ultimate guide to the best restaurants, cafés, bakeries, food trucks, and more in Cedarhurst—a must-read for anyone with an appetite for discovery.
Central Avenue: The Delicious Main Drag
When it comes to food in Cedarhurst, Central Avenue is the place to start. This thoroughfare is lined with eateries offering everything from kosher fine dining to quick shawarma wraps.
- Le Chocolat
Located at 556 Central Ave, Le Chocolat is the spot for fancy nights out or celebratory meals. Famed for its upscale dairy menu—think truffle risottos, artisanal pizzas, and French-inspired pastries—the vibe here is elegant but not stuffy. Prices are on the higher end, but the white-glove service and decadent desserts (their molten chocolate cake is legendary) make it a splurge-worthy choice.
- Cork & Slice
Just a block away at 477 Chestnut St (off Central Ave), Cork & Slice attracts date night crowds and gourmet pizza fiends alike. This modern kosher restaurant serves up creative pies (try the honey-chili brussels sprouts pizza!) alongside elevated starters and a curated wine list. Expect mid-to-high prices and a stylish, bustling atmosphere.
- Simply Sushi
Situated at 409 Central Ave, this busy spot is beloved for its fresh, chef-driven sushi and Japanese specialties. There’s a separate vegetarian menu and a hearty selection of fish rolls. Lunchtime means great deals, especially for their combo platters—don’t skip the inventive appetizers like spicy tuna nachos!
Savory Global Eats
Cedarhurst’s dining scene embraces international flavors, with a heavy nod to Mediterranean, Middle Eastern, and classic American cuisine.
- Jerusalem Pizza
On 484 Central Ave, this cozy eatery is a go-to for quick, satisfying slices, homemade eggplant parm, and crisp falafel. Popular with families and students, Jerusalem Pizza is affordable, casual, and stays open late for late-night cravings.
- Bogo Kosher
At 538 Central Ave, Bogo Kosher serves Mediterranean grilled meats, shawarma, and fresh salads. Their laffa wraps (pillowy, fresh bread stuffed with your choice of protein) are a local favorite, perfect for a quick lunch or dinner to go.
- Sushi Tokyo
Right at the corner of Cedarhurst Ave and Central Ave, this bright spot offers an inventive take on Japanese fare. The poke bowls are super fresh, and the signature sushi rolls have a loyal following. Grab a sidewalk table in warmer months for great people-watching along the main drag.
Sweet Stops: Bakeries and Dessert Havens
The bakeries of Cedarhurst are nothing short of a carb-lover's dream, ranging from traditional kosher challahs to Instagram-worthy patisserie treats.
- Ohr Bakery
No food tour of Cedarhurst is complete without mentioning Ohr Bakery at 529 Central Ave. Famed for their artisanal breads, buttery rugelach, and sticky cinnamon buns, this family-run shop draws crowds every Friday with the scent of freshly baked challah wafting down the street.
- Bunch o Bagels
On the corner of Cedarhurst Ave and Spruce St, Bunch o Bagels has the area’s best chewy bagels, schmears, and breakfast sandwiches. Their chocolate babka is a hidden gem—hands down one of the best sweet bites in the neighborhood.
- Barbara’s Cheesecakes
Tucked into a cozy storefront at 462 Central Ave, this bakery specializes in creamy New York-style cheesecakes, with rotating flavors like Oreo, raspberry swirl, and classic plain. A real slice of local tradition!
Café Culture: Chill Out and Caffeinate
Between shopping or after synagogue, locals love a pause at Cedarhurst’s growing crop of cafés.
- Caffè Latte
Nestled at 503 Central Ave, this hip café pours expertly crafted coffee drinks, matcha lattes, and serves up light lunch fare. The midday sunlit tables make a great remote work or people-watching spot. Don’t leave without sampling their pistachio croissants.
- Bagel Boss
Another mainstay, Bagel Boss at 536 Central Ave, is much more than a bagel shop. Besides their signature hand-rolled bagels, they offer a full hot/cold deli, fresh salads, and classic NYC-style coffee. The line often stretches out the door on Sunday mornings—a testament to its local legend status.
Quick Bites & Hidden Gems
Hungry for something a little off the radar? Cedarhurst’s got you covered with food trucks and lesser-known favorites.
- The Shnitzi Food Truck
Parked near the Cedarhurst LIRR station most weekdays, The Shnitzi serves up authentic Israeli schnitzel sandwiches, crispy fries, and zesty sauces. It’s a popular lunch break option for commuters and hungry teens alike—expect a crispy, satisfying bite for under $15.
- Sherry’s On the Avenue
Down a quieter stretch at 124 Cedarhurst Ave, this old-school luncheonette is a time capsule with friendly counter service, matzo ball soup, and deli sandwiches stacked high. Prices are budget-friendly, and the comfort food menu is perfect for a nostalgic, no-frills meal.
- Cohen’s Dairy Delights
A blink-and-you’ll-miss-it nook on Cedarhurst Ave, Cohen’s is a long-running local secret. The spot serves rich, homemade ice cream in classic and rotating flavors—perfect for a sweet treat while wandering the neighborhood on a warm afternoon.
Local Food Traditions: More Than a Meal
Cedarhurst’s dining scene is deeply tied to the community’s Jewish heritage, with many eateries adhering to kosher laws. Fridays mean bakeries are packed, and markets buzz as locals prepare for Shabbat. The High Holidays bring out the best in local bakeries, while Passover unleashes a flood of flourless cakes and macaroons. Many restaurants, especially on Central Avenue, close for Jewish holidays—a testament to how food and faith intertwine here.
Final Bites: Why Cedarhurst Stands Out
What makes Cedarhurst’s food scene shine isn’t just the variety—it’s the sense of community, quality ingredients, and pride local chefs bring to the table. Whether you’re craving kosher gourmet, fresh-baked breads, a bustling café vibe, or just a legendary slice of pizza, Cedarhurst offers a taste that locals swear by and visitors remember.
So, next time you find yourself in the Five Towns, set out down Central Avenue and beyond—your taste buds will thank you.